← All chapters
377 / 1113 · Psalms 22 · The United Kingdom · Undated (psalm 'of David'; debated)

My God, Why Have You Forsaken Me?

Debated

In a hospital corridor late at night, a father sits outside the intensive care ward. He has prayed every prayer he knows. Now he has only one word left, and it is 'Why?' Friends offer explanations that do not help. Some people feel guilty for even asking such a question of God. Psalm 22 gives them permission. It opens not with calm faith but with a raw cry of abandonment, and it keeps crying for a long time. Only after the whole weight of suffering has been named does the poem begin, slowly, to turn.

Where it sits in the story: In Act 3 Israel learned to bring even its darkest experiences to God in prayer. Psalm 22 is first of all one sufferer's lament, rooted in the faith of Israel's ancestors. But in Act 4 the Gospels place its opening words on Jesus' lips at the cross, and early Christians read the whole psalm as a map of his suffering and vindication.

What this chapter is doing: To give voice to the experience of feeling abandoned by God, to hold that cry together with memory of God's past faithfulness, and to show how rescue overflows into praise far beyond the one who was rescued.

Why it is read here: This psalm carries David's name (or sits in the David collection), but no heading ties it to an event. We gather these near the end of David's life — 'the sweet psalmist of Israel' (2 Samuel 23:1) — rather than guess an occasion for each. 'Of David' can mean by, for, or in the tradition of David.
The walk-through
  • 22:1–11 — 'My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?' The sufferer cries day and night without answer. Yet God is holy; the ancestors trusted and were rescued. He feels less than human, a worm scorned by all, as mockers sneer, 'He trusted the LORD — let the LORD rescue him.' Still, God has been with him since birth.
  • 22:12–18 — Enemies surround him like bulls of Bashan, roaring lions and a pack of dogs. His strength drains like water, his bones are out of joint, his heart melts, his tongue sticks to his mouth. They attack his hands and feet, stare at him and divide his clothes by casting lots.
  • 22:19–21 — The plea becomes urgent: LORD, do not be far off; rescue me from the sword, the dog, the lion's mouth and the horns of wild oxen. Then comes the turn, in a few Hebrew words: 'you have answered me.'
  • 22:22–26 — Now he praises God in the great assembly and calls all Jacob's descendants to join. God has not despised the affliction of the afflicted or hidden his face; he heard the cry. The poor will eat and be satisfied.
  • 22:27–31 — The praise spreads outward: all the ends of the earth will turn to the LORD, the families of the nations will worship, even the dead will bow, and generations yet unborn will be told that he has done it.
⚖︎ Is Psalm 22 a lament from David's life or a prophecy of the crucifixion?
Bounds
The psalm itself speaks as one sufferer in the first person; by the time of the Gospels its words were read as describing Jesus' death.
Positions
  • An individual lament, perhaps used by many sufferers, which Christians later saw fulfilled in Jesus.
  • A prophecy in which David spoke beyond his own experience of the coming Messiah's suffering.
  • A lament whose pattern of suffering and vindication Jesus deliberately took up and fulfilled, so both readings stand.
Our reading: We read it first as a genuine cry of anguish from Israel's worship, with no single event behind it, and then with the Gospel writers who heard in it the story of Jesus' death and vindication. Readers from different traditions weigh these differently.
What it showsPsalm 22 follows the familiar pattern of individual lament: complaint, trust, petition, then vow and praise. Mark 15:34 and Matthew 27:46 record Jesus crying its first line in Aramaic, the mockery at the cross echoes verses 7–8, John 19:24 cites verse 18 for the dividing of his clothes, and Hebrews 2:12 quotes verse 22.
Where the evidence stopsVerse 16 is a textual puzzle: the standard Hebrew text reads 'like a lion, my hands and feet', while the ancient Greek translation and a Dead Sea Scroll fragment support a verb, often rendered 'pierced' or 'dug'. The heading's 'Doe of the Dawn' is probably a tune name whose meaning is lost.

Key verse: Psalm 22:1  ·  So what: Psalm 22 shows that faith can include accusation, and that asking God 'why?' is not the opposite of trust. For Christians it goes further: Jesus himself prayed these words, entering the place of forsakenness. For anyone in the dark, the psalm offers no quick answer, but it does offer company — and a turn that comes only after the cry is fully voiced.

← The King Comes Home RejoicingYou have just read Psalm 21, a royal song of victory. Next comes Psalm 23, the quiet confidence of the LORD as shepherd and host.The LORD, My Shepherd and Host →
← All chapters