← All chapters
596 / 1113 · Isaiah 14 · The Divided Kingdom · c. 715 BC (the Philistia oracle: 'the year King Ahaz died'); the taunt's date debated

How You Have Fallen, Day Star

Debated
Read

When a feared dictator dies, people sometimes do not mourn. They make jokes. They sing songs in the streets that they would have been jailed for a week earlier. Isaiah 14 contains one of the oldest songs of that kind. The whole earth breathes out; the cedars of Lebanon laugh, because no woodcutter comes up against them anymore. Down in the world of the dead, old kings sit up on their thrones to greet the newcomer: so you are as weak as we are. The man who wanted to climb above the stars has maggots for a bed.

Where it sits in the story: This chapter continues Isaiah's oracles against the nations (chapters 13–23). The message for Judah is steady: the empires that trample it will themselves be brought down, and God's purpose for Zion stands. The taunt's image of a 'Day Star' falling from heaven has had a long later life. It is linked in Christian tradition with Luke 10:18 and with Satan's fall. Revelation 22:16 even calls Jesus the bright morning star.

What this chapter is doing: To promise Israel relief from its oppressors and to mock the pride of an empire's king. The chapter then applies God's fixed plan to Assyria, the power actually threatening Judah, and to Philistia, a neighbour tempted to celebrate too soon.

The walk-through
  • 14:1–3 — God will again choose Israel and settle them in their land; foreigners will join them. On the day of rest from hard service, Israel will take up this taunt against the king of Babylon.
  • 14:4–11 — The oppressor has stopped. The whole earth is at rest and breaks into song; the cypresses rejoice. Sheol, the place of the dead, stirs to meet him, and the dead kings say: you too have become weak like us. Maggots are his bed and worms his covering.
  • 14:12–21 — 'How you have fallen from heaven, Day Star, son of Dawn!' He had said he would climb to heaven, set his throne above God's stars on the mount of assembly in the far north, and make himself like the Most High. Instead he is brought down to the Pit, his body thrown out unburied, and his sons are to be slaughtered.
  • 14:22–27 — God will sweep Babylon with the broom of destruction. Then a sworn oath: God will break Assyria in his own land and on his mountains. This is the plan for the whole earth, and no one can turn back his outstretched hand.
  • 14:28–32 — In the year King Ahaz died: Philistia should not celebrate that the rod which struck it is broken, because from the serpent's root will come an adder. What answer should be given to foreign messengers? The LORD has founded Zion, and the afflicted of his people will find refuge there.
⚖︎ Who is the 'Day Star, son of Dawn' (Isaiah 14:12), later called 'Lucifer'?
Bounds
The taunt was composed in Isaiah's 8th century or, as many scholars think, as late as the 6th century BC; the Satan reading is found in Christian writers from about AD 200 onward.
Positions
  • A human king, pictured through myth: the song is aimed at 'the king of Babylon' (14:4) and he is plainly a mortal, with a corpse and sons (14:19–21). The Hebrew 'Helel son of Shachar' ('shining one, son of dawn') probably refers to the morning star (the planet Venus). Scholars often compare it to an old story of a star-god who tried to rise too high and was thrown down.
  • A king re-applied: some scholars think the taunt first mocked an Assyrian king — Sargon II, killed in battle in 705 BC with his body never recovered, is often suggested — and was later applied to Babylon. Others think it was written for a Babylonian king, left unnamed.
  • A picture of Satan's fall: early Christian writers such as Origen and Tertullian read verses 12–15 also as describing the devil's fall through pride, linking them with Luke 10:18. The Latin Vulgate translated the Hebrew as 'lucifer' ('light-bringer', a Latin name for the morning star), and through the King James Version this became a name for Satan.
Our reading: In its setting the song mocks a real, proud king, using the language of a star that tried to climb too high. Reading it as a picture of Satan's pride is a later reading, widely held in Christian tradition; it is best seen as an application, not the passage's first meaning. 'Lucifer' is a Latin translation, not a Hebrew name.
What it showsIsaiah 14:13–14 uses imagery also found in Canaanite religious texts from Ugarit, such as a divine assembly on the mountain Zaphon ('the far north'). 'The year King Ahaz died' ties the Philistia oracle to Isaiah's own time, probably around 715 BC.
Where the evidence stopsWhich king the taunt first mocked cannot be proved, and the date of Ahaz's death depends on disputed chronology. The Hebrew does not name Satan; the link to Satan is a later reading, not the passage's plain first sense.

Key verse: Isaiah 14:12  ·  So what: Most of us will never be emperors, but the attitude in verses 13–14 — I will climb, I will sit, I will make myself like the Most High — is ordinary human pride magnified. The song shows where it ends. For people who have lived under cruel power, the chapter also allows a hard-edged relief when the oppressor falls, and does not ask them to pretend otherwise.

← The Oracle Against BabylonYou have just read Isaiah's oracle of Babylon's fall and the darkened Day of the LORD (Isaiah 13). Next, Isaiah turns to Moab, Judah's neighbour east of the Dead Sea, and weeps over its ruin (Isaiah 15).A Lament for Moab →
← All chapters