← All chapters
397 / 1113 · Psalms 58 · The United Kingdom · Undated; read with David's later years, c. 970 BC (debated)

When the Judges Are Corrupt

Debated

There are families who have waited twenty years for a land case to be decided, while the other side paid the right clerk and the file kept disappearing. There are villages where everyone knows who killed whom, and everyone knows nothing will happen. What do you pray in a place like that? Psalm 58 is the answer of someone who has stopped being polite. It is one of the Bible's imprecatory psalms — prayers calling down judgment — and its language is shocking. It is also aimed at a very specific target: those who hold power to judge and use it to crush.

Where it sits in the story: In Israel's story (Act 3) the law demanded judges who would not take bribes or favour the powerful, and the prophets thunder when that fails. Psalm 58 is that demand turned into prayer. The New Testament will add 'love your enemies' (Matthew 5:44), yet it keeps the same conviction — 'leave room for God's wrath' (Romans 12:19) — and the Bible's closing act (Act 6) promises a final, just judgment.

What this chapter is doing: To cry out against corrupt justice without taking vengeance into one's own hands — handing the case, in the most vivid language available, to God, the only judge who cannot be bought.

Why it is read here: This psalm carries David's name (or sits in the David collection), but no heading ties it to an event. We gather these near the end of David's life — 'the sweet psalmist of Israel' (2 Samuel 23:1) — rather than guess an occasion for each. 'Of David' can mean by, for, or in the tradition of David.
The walk-through
  • 58:1–2 — Do you rulers really speak justly? The opening word is uncertain in Hebrew — 'mighty ones', 'gods', or 'in silence' — but the charge is clear: in their hearts they devise wrongs and with their hands they deal out violence.
  • 58:3–5 — The wicked go astray from birth, speaking lies. Their venom is like a snake's — a deaf cobra that stops its ears so the charmer's music cannot reach it, however skilled he is.
  • 58:6–9 — Break the teeth in their mouths, O God; tear out the young lions' fangs. Let them drain away like water, shrivel like trampled grass, dissolve like a snail, never see the sun like a stillborn child — swept away faster than a cooking pot can feel the heat of burning thorns.
  • 58:10–11 — The righteous will rejoice to see vengeance, bathing their feet in the blood of the wicked — a battlefield image of total reversal. Then people will say: surely there is a reward for the righteous; surely there is a God who judges on earth.
⚖︎ How should Christians read a psalm that asks God to break people's teeth?
Bounds
From treating the curses as sub-Christian and not to be prayed, to praying them fully as the voice of the oppressed.
Positions
  • The curses reflect an earlier stage of revelation that the teaching of Jesus supersedes; they are read, not prayed.
  • They are legitimate prayers of the wronged, handing vengeance to God rather than taking it, and they remain usable — especially by the victims of injustice.
  • They are read typologically or against spiritual evil, and ultimately fulfilled in God's final judgment rather than aimed at particular people.
Our reading: We read Psalm 58 as an honest prayer for justice that surrenders vengeance to God. Its images are hyperbolic war-poetry, and it sits alongside, not against, the call to love enemies.
What it showsThe snake-charmer image reflects a practice known in the ancient Near East, and the psalm belongs to the recognised group of imprecatory psalms, whose curses echo the covenant language of judgment on injustice.
Where the evidence stopsThe first verse's key word is textually uncertain, so whether human judges or divine beings ('gods') are addressed is debated; no event is named, and 'of David' can mean by, for or in his tradition.

Key verse: Psalm 58:11  ·  So what: This psalm is hard to pray, and it should be. But it is not a charter for revenge; it is a prayer that gives rage to God instead of acting it out. People who have never faced corrupt power may find it barbaric. Those who have often find in it the dignity of being taken seriously. Read beside Jesus' command to love enemies, it asks us to long for justice without becoming the destroyer.

← Wings Like a DoveYou have just read Psalm 55, a prayer out of betrayal in a violent city. Next, Psalm 61 calls to God 'from the end of the earth' — a quieter cry for a rock higher than oneself.From the End of the Earth →
Sources & further reading
← All chapters