← All chapters
215 / 1113 · Deuteronomy 19 · Exodus & Wilderness · 15th or 13th century BC (debated); final written form also debated

Cities of Refuge

Debated
Read

Two men are cutting wood. An axe-head flies off its handle and strikes one of them dead. The other is not a murderer, but in a village where family honour demands blood for blood, the dead man's brother may already be running after him. Anyone who has seen a road accident turn into a mob beating knows how fast grief becomes vengeance. Deuteronomy 19 uses exactly that axe-head example. Its answer is not to forbid grief, but to build roads to safe cities, so the truth can be heard before anyone is killed.

Where it sits in the story: This is Act 3, where God shapes Israel's shared life into a just society. Numbers 35 first described the cities of refuge; Moses now repeats the plan for the land ahead, and Joshua 20 later names the cities. The chapter's concern for 'innocent blood' and fair witnesses runs forward to the prophets, and to Jesus, who quotes both the rule of two or three witnesses and 'eye for an eye' (Matthew 18:16; 5:38).

What this chapter is doing: To keep the land from being stained with innocent blood by separating accident from murder, and by making courts depend on more than one person's word.

The walk-through
  • 19:1–7 — Three cities are to be set apart in the land, with roads kept in good repair, so a person who killed without intent or old hatred can reach safety before the 'avenger of blood' catches him in hot anger.
  • 19:8–13 — If God enlarges their territory, three more cities are added. But the refuge is not a hiding place for murderers: one who killed out of hatred is to be handed back by his own town's elders to face justice.
  • 19:14 — A one-verse law with a long reach: do not move a neighbour's boundary stone. In a farming society, shifting a marker quietly steals a family's livelihood.
  • 19:15–21 — One witness is never enough to convict; it takes two or three. A malicious witness exposed by the judges receives the penalty he tried to bring on the other person. The chapter ends with the measure-for-measure rule: life for life, eye for eye.
What it showsBlood vengeance by kin and the use of sanctuary for accidental killers are well known in ancient and traditional societies; the 'eye for eye' principle also appears in the Code of Hammurabi.
Where the evidence stopsNo archaeological evidence confirms the cities working as refuges, and scholars debate whether the lists in Numbers, Deuteronomy and Joshua describe a system that was actually run or an ideal.

Key verse: Deuteronomy 19:15  ·  So what: Many of today's legal protections echo this chapter: the difference between murder and accidental death, the need for more than one witness, and penalties for perjury. The 'eye for eye' rule, often heard as savage, was in its setting a limit on revenge and a guide for judges, not permission for private payback. Jesus later pressed his followers further still, beyond fairness to mercy.

← A Prophet Like MosesYou have just read the promise of a prophet like Moses (Deuteronomy 18). Next come the rules for going to war (Deuteronomy 20), including some of the hardest commands in the book.The Rules of War →
Sources & further reading
← All chapters