← All chapters
64 / 1113 · Job 14 · The Patriarchs · Setting: patriarchal age (date of writing unknown)

Hope for a Tree

Debated
Read

Anyone who has watched a neem tree cut back to a stump knows what happens after the first monsoon rain: small green shoots push out of wood that looked finished. Farmers count on it. Job has watched this too, and it makes him envious. A tree, he says, has hope. Cut it down and the scent of water brings it back. But a human being lies down and does not rise. This is one of the saddest chapters in the Bible, and also one of the most searching, because in the middle of his despair Job dares to ask the question every grieving person asks: if someone dies, will they live again?

Where it sits in the story: Job 14 closes his reply to Zophar and with it the first round of the debate. In the Bible's larger story this is the fall felt from the inside — death as the shadow over every life. The question Job asks here is left open. Much later, the Bible's story answers it with resurrection; but Job does not know that, and the book lets him feel the full weight of not knowing.

What this chapter is doing: To state the human condition plainly — short, troubled, ending in the grave — and to let Job reach, briefly, for a hope beyond death before the reach falls back.

Why it is read here: Job is placed here because its world — wealth counted in flocks, a father offering sacrifice for his own family, lifespans past a century — is the world of the patriarchs. When the book was written is unknown; estimates run from Solomon's age to after the exile. We place it by its setting, not its authorship.
The walk-through
  • 14:1–6 — Human beings are born of women, live briefly and full of trouble, and fade like a flower or a shadow. Why would God bother to watch and judge such a fragile thing? Job asks God to look away and let him finish his days like a hired worker finishing his shift.
  • 14:7–12 — The tree image: a stump sprouts again at the scent of water. A person breathes his last and is gone, like a lake that dries up. Until the heavens are no more, the dead will not wake.
  • 14:13–17 — Then a daring wish: hide me in Sheol, the realm of the dead, until your anger has passed, and set a time to remember me. 'If a man dies, will he live again?' Job imagines God calling and himself answering, his sins sealed up in a bag and put away.
  • 14:18–22 — The wish collapses. As mountains crumble and water wears away stone, so God wears away human hope. The dead do not even know whether their children rise or fall. Only pain and grief remain.
What it showsThe picture of Sheol as a shadowy place where the dead know little matches how much of the Old Testament speaks about death before a clear hope of resurrection appears in later texts such as Daniel 12.
Where the evidence stopsJob's question in verse 14 is a question, not a doctrine; reading a settled belief in resurrection into this chapter goes beyond what the text itself says.

Key verse: Job 14:14  ·  So what: Many readers have prayed Job 14 at a graveside because it does not pretend. It names the shortness of life and the silence of death, and it still asks God the big question. Christians read this chapter hearing an answer Job did not have; but even they gain from sitting honestly with his question before rushing to the answer.

← Job Demands a HearingYou have just read Job demanding a hearing from God (Job 13); here he wonders whether the dead can live again. Next, Eliphaz opens the second round of speeches with a sharper rebuke (Job 15).Eliphaz Loses Patience →
Sources & further reading
← All chapters